Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices For 2026
Cold, creamy treats are the main attraction on the Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu, which offers plenty of choices for anyone with a sweet tooth. The menu features frozen custard, concretes, sundaes, shakes, malts, floats, and other specialty desserts made for different tastes.
You can keep your order simple with a classic frozen custard or choose a more indulgent combination with toppings, sauces, candies, or other mix-ins. Seasonal and specialty creations can also give regular customers something new to try.
Exploring the Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu before visiting can help you decide between its many frozen desserts. This guide covers custard, concretes, sundaes, shakes, malts, toppings, specialty treats, and other sweet options available for your next visit.
Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices
An Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices helps you explore this Missouri-born chain’s rich, creamy dessert lineup before you visit. Founded in 1986 in Osage Beach, Missouri, Andy’s has grown into the largest frozen custard-only chain in the United States, with more than 190 locations across 15 states, all built around a signature custard base that is noticeably denser and richer than standard soft-serve ice cream.
Cones & Cups
Cones and cups are the simplest way to enjoy Andy’s signature frozen custard, and this category gives guests a straightforward entry point into the menu before exploring the more elaborate concretes and sundaes elsewhere on the board.
The classic vanilla or chocolate custard forms the base for nearly every item on the menu, and ordering it plain in a cup or cone is the best way for first-time guests to taste the custard itself before adding any mix-ins or toppings. Andy’s offers four sizes across this category, giving guests meaningful control over both portion and price.
The Small Cone or Cup starts around $3.49 and contains roughly 200 calories, making it one of the more affordable and lighter options on the entire menu. The Medium steps up to about $4.29 and 270 calories, while the Large reaches $4.99 and around 400 calories for guests with a bigger appetite.
The Jumbo size rounds out the lineup for guests who want the most custard possible in a simple cup or cone format, typically priced around $5.49 and delivering a noticeably larger portion than the Large size. Because the custard itself is richer than typical soft-serve, even the Small size tends to feel more indulgent than an equivalent size at a standard ice cream shop.
| Size | Price | Estimated Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Small Cone or Cup | $3.49 | 200 |
| Medium Cone or Cup | $4.29 | 270 |
| Large Cone or Cup | $4.99 | 400 |
| Jumbo Cone or Cup | $5.49 | 480 |
Concretes
Concretes are Andy’s signature format, blending the rich custard base with candy, cookie, or fruit mix-ins into a thick, spoonable treat that has become the item most closely associated with the brand across its 15-state footprint.
The Snowmonster is one of the most popular concretes on the menu and is frequently recommended to first-time guests alongside the Butter Pecan for its balanced sweetness that is not overly rich compared to some of the more chocolate-forward options nearby on the board.
For guests who want something richer, the Triple Chocolate and the BootDaddy concretes lean heavily into chocolate flavor, appealing to chocolate enthusiasts who want the most indulgent option available. The Ooey Gooey concrete rounds out the richest end of the lineup, delivering what many regulars consider the most intense caramel experience on the entire menu.
Every concrete showcases the same signature creamy custard base, and despite the higher calorie counts compared to a plain cone or cup, many guests consider the indulgence worth it specifically because of the thick texture and generous mix-ins that set a concrete apart from a standard blended treat elsewhere in the fast-food dessert category.
Customers often return specifically for their favorite concrete combination, and the variety of mix-ins keeps the menu exciting for repeat visits, since nearly any candy or cookie mix-in can be combined with either the vanilla or chocolate custard base.
| Item | Price | Estimated Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Snowmonster Concrete (medium) | $6.49 | 780 |
| Butter Pecan Concrete (medium) | $6.49 | 740 |
| Triple Chocolate Concrete (medium) | $6.99 | 860 |
| BootDaddy Concrete (medium) | $6.99 | 890 |
| Ooey Gooey Concrete (medium) | $6.99 | 900 |
Sundaes
Sundaes at Andy’s combine frozen custard with sauces, fruit, nuts, and whipped toppings, and the menu includes options ranging from smaller portions designed for kids up to larger, more elaborate specialty creations for guests with a bigger sweet tooth.
The Hot Fudge Sundae remains one of the most classic and consistently ordered items in this category, pairing the signature vanilla custard with warm hot fudge sauce, whipped cream, and a cherry for a straightforward, familiar dessert that has remained largely unchanged since Andy’s earliest days.
Fruit-topped sundaes round out the lighter end of this category, combining custard with strawberry or other fruit toppings for guests who want something a bit less rich than the chocolate and caramel-heavy options nearby on the menu.
Kids’ sundaes provide an easy introduction to the Andy’s menu for younger guests, offering smaller portions at a lower price point than the standard adult-size sundaes, while still including the same signature custard base used throughout the rest of the menu.
Specialty sundaes occasionally rotate onto the menu as limited-time offerings, giving regulars a reason to check back throughout the year for new topping combinations beyond the standard, always-available sundae lineup.
| Item | Price | Estimated Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Hot Fudge Sundae (medium) | $5.49 | 590 |
| Strawberry Sundae (medium) | $5.49 | 520 |
| Kids Sundae | $3.29 | 280 |
Shakes, Malts & Splits
Shakes, malts, and splits round out the blended and multi-topping side of the Andy’s Frozen Custard menu, giving guests several more ways to enjoy the signature custard base beyond the standard cones, concretes, and sundaes.
Malts and shakes both use the same rich custard base blended into a drinkable format, and the malt version adds a distinct malted flavor for guests who prefer that classic diner-style taste over a standard shake. Both are available in the same core flavors used throughout the rest of the menu.
Banana splits round out the specialty dessert lineup, combining custard with banana, multiple sauces, and toppings for one of the more elaborate and shareable options on the entire menu, often ordered for guests celebrating a birthday or other special occasion.
Because shakes and malts are blended rather than served as a solid scoop, they travel differently for takeout compared to a concrete or sundae, and they are generally best enjoyed shortly after ordering rather than transported over a longer distance.
Specialty shake flavors occasionally rotate onto the menu alongside the standard chocolate and vanilla options, giving regulars a reason to try something new without stepping outside the familiar shake and malt format they already enjoy.
| Item | Price | Estimated Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Chocolate or Vanilla Shake (medium) | $5.99 | 680 |
| Malt (medium) | $6.29 | 700 |
| Banana Split | $7.49 | 950 |
Pints, Quarts & Takeout
Pints and quarts round out the Andy’s Frozen Custard menu for guests who want to bring the brand’s signature custard home rather than eating it on the spot, and this category tends to offer strong value for a group or family compared to ordering individual servings.
A pint of Andy’s Frozen Custard typically costs between $3.69 and $4.44 depending on flavor and location, making it one of the more affordable ways to enjoy the custard at home over the following several days, provided it is stored properly in the freezer.
Quarts scale up from the pint size for guests hosting a gathering or simply wanting a larger supply on hand, and both sizes are available in the same classic vanilla and chocolate flavors used throughout the rest of the menu, along with rotating seasonal flavors depending on the time of year.
Because Andy’s custard is not dairy-free, guests with dairy restrictions should note that most menu items, including the takeout pints and quarts, contain dairy, though some locations may offer limited dairy-free alternatives like Italian ice for guests who need to avoid dairy entirely.
Takeout pints and quarts are a popular choice for guests who want to stock the freezer with a favorite flavor rather than making a separate trip every time a craving strikes, and they also make an easy, affordable gift or party contribution for guests attending a gathering.
| Item | Price | Estimated Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Pint (takeout) | $3.69 – $4.44 | 680 |
| Quart (takeout) | $6.99 – $7.99 | 1,360 |
| Bottled Water | $1.69 | 0 |
Tips For Ordering Andy’s Frozen Custard
Starting with a Snowmonster or Butter Pecan concrete is a good way to sample Andy’s signature format if it is your first visit, since both are frequently recommended for their balanced sweetness compared to the richer chocolate-forward options.
Choosing a Small or Medium cone rather than a concrete is the easiest way to keep your order both lighter and more affordable, since the concretes and specialty sundaes carry meaningfully more calories and cost than a plain cup or cone.
Buying a pint or quart to take home is worth considering if you want to enjoy the custard over several days rather than in one sitting, and it generally works out to a lower per-serving cost than ordering individual cones or concretes on repeat visits.
Asking about seasonal flavors and limited-time concretes is worth doing on each visit, since Andy’s rotates specialty items throughout the year beyond the core, always-available menu covered in this guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a concrete and a sundae at Andy’s?
A concrete blends the custard with mix-ins like candy, cookies, or fruit into a single, thick, spoonable texture, while a sundae layers custard with sauces and toppings like hot fudge or fruit without fully blending them together. Both use the same signature custard base.
How much does a pint of Andy’s Frozen Custard cost?
A pint of Andy’s Frozen Custard typically costs between $3.69 and $4.44 depending on the flavor and location. Quarts are also available for larger takeout orders, generally priced between $6.99 and $7.99.
Is Andy’s Frozen Custard dairy-free?
No. Andy’s Frozen Custard is not dairy-free, and the majority of menu items contain dairy. Some locations may offer limited dairy-free alternatives like Italian ice, but it is best to check with your local store if you need to avoid dairy entirely.
What is Andy’s most popular menu item?
The Snowmonster concrete is one of the most popular and frequently recommended items on the Andy’s menu, along with the Butter Pecan concrete, both known for their balanced sweetness compared to the richer chocolate-based options.
Are Andy’s Frozen Custard prices the same at every location?
No. Prices can vary by location and size, though a small cup or cone generally starts around $3.50, with larger sizes and specialty items costing more. The prices in this guide reflect typical national averages, so it is worth checking your local menu before ordering.
Final Word
An Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices makes it much easier to plan your next sweet treat before you even pull up to the window. From simple cones and cups to signature concretes, sundaes, shakes, and takeout pints, having a clear price list helps you compare options and pick a treat that fits your budget and craving.
Keeping an Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices guide on hand also saves time when you are deciding between a light cone and a fully loaded concrete, or planning a takeout pint for later in the week. Since prices can vary by location and change over time, checking with your local Andy’s before ordering is always a smart choice. With the right treat, you can enjoy Andy’s signature frozen custard without spending more than you planned.
